Are Local Councils' High Debt Levels a Cause for Concern? Experts Weigh In

A recent report by Moody's Investors Service has highlighted the high debt levels of several local councils in England, raising concerns about their financial stability. However, these councils have defended their investment strategies, citing the positive impact of their assets and income streams. In this article, we delve into the details of these councils' financial strategies and seek expert opinions on the potential risks and benefits. Let's explore whether these high debt levels are a cause for concern or a sound financial approach.

Understanding the Analysis by Moody's Investors Service

An overview of the report and its findings

The analysis by Moody's Investors Service titled 'More to fail as weak governance amplifies the impact of property and rates cycles' sheds light on the high debt levels of local councils in England. The report examines how much councils have borrowed relative to their core spending power, housing revenue account income, and total borrowing. Let's delve into the key findings of this report.

Councils Defending Their Financial Strategies

Insights from councils named in the report

Several councils named in the report have robustly defended their financial strategies. Mole Valley DC, for instance, argues that its debt is a result of an asset investment strategy that has been generating income to support services. Uttlesford DC highlights the positive income stream from its commercial investments, while Spelthorne BC emphasizes its successful management of its portfolio. Let's explore the councils' perspectives in more detail.

Mole Valley DC's Asset Investment Strategy

The rationale behind Mole Valley DC's borrowing

Mole Valley DC, which the report states has borrowed £103m, justifies its debt by highlighting its asset investment strategy. According to Stephen Cooksey, the leader of Mole Valley DC, the income generated from these properties more than covers the cost of the debt. In fact, the net income from the investment property portfolio supports the services provided to residents. Let's delve deeper into Mole Valley DC's asset investment strategy and its financial impact.

Uttlesford DC's Commercial Investment Portfolio

The financial benefits of Uttlesford DC's commercial investments

Uttlesford DC, with a borrowing of around £302m, firmly defends its financial strategy. The council highlights that the running costs of its commercial investments are covered by tenants, and substantial income is received. Neil Hargreaves, the council's portfolio holder for finance and the economy, emphasizes the positive ongoing income stream from the commercial property investment portfolio. Let's explore the details of Uttlesford DC's commercial investment portfolio and its financial implications.

Spelthorne BC's Successful Portfolio Management

How Spelthorne BC has effectively managed its high debt levels

Spelthorne BC's leader, Joane Sexton, confirms that the council has borrowed around £1.1bn but asserts that it has successfully managed its portfolio for the past five years. The council generates significant income from its commercial portfolio, which covers the cost of financing the debt and provides a net income stream. Additionally, Spelthorne BC's sinking fund acts as a safety net to cover any dips in income. Let's explore the details of Spelthorne BC's successful portfolio management and risk mitigation strategies.

Expert Opinion on Councils' High Debt Levels

Insights from Rob Whiteman, Chief Executive of CIPFA

Rob Whiteman, Chief Executive of the Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy (CIPFA), provides expert insights into the issue of high debt levels among local councils. While he acknowledges that investing in regeneration is a good strategy, he cautions against councils funding commercial investment projects that may not be financially viable. Whiteman emphasizes the importance of understanding the council's role in land assembly and regeneration. Let's delve into Whiteman's expert opinion and its implications for local councils.


While the high debt levels of local councils in England have raised concerns, the councils named in the report have provided strong justifications for their borrowing. Mole Valley DC, Uttlesford DC, and Spelthorne BC have all highlighted the positive impact of their investment strategies, with income streams covering the cost of debt and supporting essential services. Additionally, expert opinions from Rob Whiteman emphasize the need for councils to carefully consider the financial viability of their investments.

Overall, it is important to recognize that while high debt levels may initially raise eyebrows, the financial strategies and income-generating assets of these councils provide a level of stability and sustainability. As long as the revenue consequences of the debt are manageable, these councils can continue to provide essential services to their residents.


Are these councils at risk of financial instability due to their high debt levels?

While high debt levels may raise concerns, the councils named in the report have defended their financial strategies, highlighting the positive impact of their investment portfolios and income streams. As long as the revenue consequences of the debt are manageable, these councils can continue to operate effectively.

What are the potential risks associated with high debt levels for local councils?

High debt levels can pose risks if the revenue generated from investments and income streams is not sufficient to cover the cost of debt. Additionally, economic downturns or changes in market conditions can impact the value of assets and the ability to generate income. It is crucial for councils to carefully manage their debt and regularly assess the financial viability of their investments.

How can local councils ensure the sustainability of their services amid rising costs and uncertain funding?

Local councils can ensure the sustainability of their services by implementing robust financial strategies, diversifying their income streams, and regularly reviewing their investments. It is also important for councils to actively seek alternative funding sources and engage in effective cost management practices. By continuously monitoring their financial position and adapting to changing circumstances, councils can navigate challenges and continue to provide essential services to their communities.

Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post